A New Era for the Ballroom: Sarah Jane Nader and Hailey Bills Make History on DWTS Season 35

The glitz and glamour of the ballroom are preparing for a transformative moment as Dancing with the Stars returns for its milestone 35th season. Among the highly anticipated pairings, the spotlight has firmly fixed itself on the all-female duo of Sarah Jane Nader and professional dancer Hailey Bills. Their partnership has not only sparked intense media speculation regarding their undeniable chemistry but has also become a focal point of cultural conversation regarding representation in primetime television.

As the premiere date approaches, the excitement surrounding the pair has reached a fever pitch, punctuated by public endorsements from those closest to the contestants, including a glowing reaction from Sarah Jane’s sister, the renowned model Brooks Nader.


Main Facts: A Historic Partnership

Season 35 of Dancing with the Stars marks a significant shift in the show’s legacy. When the cameras begin rolling on September 15 and 16, 2026, on ABC and Disney+, Sarah Jane Nader and Hailey Bills will step onto the floor as the third same-sex partnership in the show’s history.

This inclusion follows a trajectory of progress for the long-running competition series. The duo joins the ranks of trailblazers like JoJo Siwa and Jenna Johnson, who captivated audiences in Season 30, and the high-energy pairing of Shangela and Gleb Savchenko in Season 31. By embracing same-sex partnerships, the production is signaling a commitment to modernizing the traditional ballroom aesthetic, which has historically relied on rigid gender roles.

Sarah Jane Nader, who has previously been candid about her bisexuality, enters the competition with a profile that has been subject to significant public interest, particularly following her high-profile summer outing with comedian Pete Davidson. However, as rehearsals intensify, the focus has shifted entirely from her personal life to her technical prowess and the burgeoning "synergy" she shares with Bills.


Chronology: The Road to the Ballroom

The narrative of Nader and Bills’ partnership began long before the first live show. In the weeks leading up to the announcement of the official cast, rumors swirled regarding the potential pairings. When the final roster was revealed, the chemistry between the two was almost immediately apparent.

The Pre-Season Buzz

The public’s first real look at their connection occurred off-stage. Paparazzi photos captured the two leaving a dance studio together, hands clasped, signaling an intimacy that went beyond a mere professional requirement. The images circulated rapidly across social media and entertainment outlets, fueling fan theories about the strength of their bond.

Official Announcements and Training

Following the photo leak, the production team confirmed that the pair would be working under the guidance of the show’s seasoned choreographers. Insiders report that the training sessions have been grueling, yet characterized by a mutual respect and an uncanny ability to mirror one another’s movements. This "synergy," as described by those close to the production, is expected to translate into high scores when the judges—Derek Hough, Carrie Ann Inaba, and Bruno Tonioli—take their seats at the dais.


Supporting Data: A Star-Studded Lineup

The competition for the Mirrorball Trophy is steeper than ever. Season 35 features an eclectic mix of talent spanning various sectors of entertainment, sports, and social media. The full list of competitors includes:

  • Tatyana Ali and Jan Ravnik
  • Tyler Cameron and Sharna Burgess
  • Giada De Laurentiis and Alan Bersten
  • Jenna Dewan and Val Chmerkovskiy
  • Ezra Frech and Daniella Karagach
  • Amber Glenn and Pasha Pashkov
  • Taylor Hanson and Britt Stewart
  • Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas
  • Conner Leavitt and Adele Zaikman
  • Ciara Miller and Brandon Armstrong
  • Jackson Olson and Emma Slater
  • Guillermo Rodriguez and Witney Carson
  • Harry Shum Jr. and Jenna Johnson
  • Julia Stiles and Ezra Sosa
  • Connor Wood and Rylee Arnold

With such a diverse array of contestants, the pressure on Nader and Bills to maintain their momentum is immense. However, the unique nature of their partnership provides a narrative arc that many viewers find compelling, potentially giving them an edge in audience voting—a critical component of the Dancing with the Stars scoring system.


Official Responses: The Nader Family Weighs In

Perhaps the most vocal supporter of the partnership has been Brooks Nader. In a recent interview with TMZ, the American model didn’t shy away from expressing her enthusiasm for her sister’s journey.

"It’s iconic," Brooks remarked, clearly proud of the path Sarah Jane has chosen. She noted that the two women share "great vibes" and that their "synergy" is palpable, even to an outside observer. Brooks’ endorsement is significant; she is a prominent voice in the Nader family and has often been the one to provide lighthearted, public commentary on Sarah Jane’s personal life, including her past public dates. By framing the partnership as "iconic," Brooks has validated the cultural weight of the pairing, elevating it from a simple casting choice to a moment of social significance.

While neither Sarah Jane nor Hailey has officially commented on the "romance" rumors, their body language and the professional praise they have heaped upon one another suggest a partnership built on genuine friendship and mutual admiration.


Implications: The Evolution of Ballroom Dance

The inclusion of Nader and Bills as a same-sex pair is not merely a casting novelty; it represents a fundamental shift in the Dancing with the Stars brand.

Breaking Gender Norms

Traditional ballroom dance is rooted in centuries of gender-coded choreography, where the "lead" and "follow" roles were strictly demarcated by the gender of the dancers. By introducing same-sex pairings, the show is forcing a re-evaluation of these standards. When two women or two men dance together, the roles of lead and follow become fluid, allowing for a more creative, inclusive, and modern interpretation of the art form.

The "Siwa Effect"

The success of JoJo Siwa and Jenna Johnson in Season 30 established that the audience is not only accepting of, but actively excited by, same-sex pairings. By finishing as runners-up, Siwa and Johnson proved that these duos are competitive and capable of technical excellence. Nader and Bills are effectively building upon that foundation, normalizing the sight of two women on the dance floor and potentially paving the way for more inclusive casting in future seasons.

Impact on Viewership

As the show transitions into a multi-platform environment—broadcasting on both ABC and Disney+—the demographic reach of Dancing with the Stars is expanding. Younger, more socially conscious viewers are increasingly drawn to shows that reflect the realities of modern identity. The "iconic" status already assigned to Nader and Bills serves as a marketing engine, drawing in fans who might otherwise be disinterested in traditional ballroom competitions.


Conclusion: Looking Toward the Premiere

As the September premiere approaches, the stage is set for a season defined by both intense competition and social progress. With hosts Alfonso Ribeiro and Julianne Hough steering the ship, and a panel of judges known for their discerning eyes, Sarah Jane Nader and Hailey Bills will have to prove that their chemistry can withstand the scrutiny of the technical scores.

Regardless of where they finish in the final standings, their impact is already secured. By challenging conventions and capturing the public’s imagination, Nader and Bills have ensured that Season 35 will be remembered as a pivotal chapter in the history of Dancing with the Stars. For the Nader family, the fans, and the contestants alike, the focus remains on the music, the movement, and the undeniable synergy that promises to make this season the most memorable one yet.